Author Claims Assassin’s Creed Set-Up Was His Idea (49 posts)

← Back To Forum
  • Profile picture of MysticHeero MysticHeero said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    they will eventually get to the point of “I’m suing ______ because I released my _____ before them and it had words in it!” It really does get pathetic

    sprite
  • Profile picture of Anja R. Anja R. said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    I really hope they kick his ass soon, there are similarities, yes, but not as much as to call it solen :/

     

    sprite
  • Profile picture of Wolf Wolf said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    The book was written in 2002.  It was released in print, limited run, in Jan 2003. http://www.abebooks.com/servlet/BookDetailsPL?bi=7359234959&searchurl=an%3DJohn%2BBeiswenger%26sts%3Dt%26tn%3DLink%26x%3D76%26y%3D10    

     

    I find it extremely hard to believe that, with as much hype as the AC series has received, he’d never heard of it.  

    The similarities are flimsy. A battle of good versus evil? Mentioning God, Jesus, Forbidden Fruit and Eden?   LOTS of books do that. LOTS of books written prior to 2002.    

     

      I bet if someone was really tenacious enough, they could find books written well before 2002 that have the same premise of some sort of scientific breakthrough/discovery of a device that allows you to access an ancestor’s memories, or relive a past life.    

     

      Does that mean those authors should sue this guy for copyright infringments? No, of course not. that’s as silly as this.  

     

       As far as the complaint of using ‘specific and exact words’- you CANNOT copyright exact words. Period.

     

         This would be akin to the descendants of Vladimr Bartol sueing Ubisoft for using his book, Alamut, as the basis of the story in the first game.

     

    As far as comparing LInk to Total REcall- not the same thing. In Total REcall, they remove EXISTING memories and you have to recover them. Not relive an ancestor’s memories.

     

    This would be something along the lines of George Lucas sueing Joss Whedon because Firefly is set in space, in the future, has a fringe element, has a corrupt government, etc, similar to Star Wars.

     

    Similar, but no where near copyright infringing.

    sprite
  • Profile picture of Wolf Wolf said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    And he’s not trying to delay ACIII, he’s trying to STOP IT FROM BEING RELEASED, along with any future merchandise.

     

    The suit requests that damages of no less than $1.05 million be awarded to Beiswenger, with that amount rising to $5.25 million if the judge rules that Ubisoft for wilfully infringed his copyrights. It also requests that the judge prevent the release of Assassin’s Creed III and all related products.”

     

    http://www.gamespot.com/news/ubisoft-sued-over-assassins-creed-plot-6372179

     

    full complaint can be found via link here-

    http://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2012-04-18-ubisoft-sued-by-author-over-assassins-creed-copyright-infringement

     

     

     

    sprite
  • Profile picture of Dylan Black Dylan Black said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    If he’s wanting to get paid for supposedly having been ripped off why would he want to stop the release instead of collect on it? Something else is motivating this guy

    sprite
  • Profile picture of Wolf Wolf said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    The man is named in 20-21 different patents in the US, so he’s not stupid by any stretch of the word. Something else is defintely motivating him, quite possibly the failure of his books to reach critical acclaim- which being they seem to be generic sci fi literary tropes, ie, run of the mill, this should come as no surprise to him.

    sprite
  • Profile picture of Dylan Black Dylan Black said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    If its the failure of his generic book (started reading and put it down after like 50 pages) then that’s his fault maybe he should have put a little more thought into before he tried merging like 5 different things into 1

    sprite
  • Profile picture of pedgz pedgz said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    i heard vladimir bartol also wants a piece of the action from the ac games, hahaha.

    sprite
  • Profile picture of Dylan Black Dylan Black said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    *bashes head against counter* stupid people. :-@

    sprite
  • Profile picture of pierre s. pierre s. said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    I guess when he heard it’s going to be their biggest release, he jumped on the opportunity to make money..

    sprite
  • Profile picture of Anja R. Anja R. said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    Any news on this?

    Would like to know how they settle it.

    sprite
  • Profile picture of pedgz pedgz said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    i missed the part where he also sued gametrailers.com…

    http://www.digitaltrends.com/gaming/author-sues-ubisoft-gametrailers-over-assassins-creed-storyline/

     

    …which is surprising considering most, if not all, of the ac trailers were released in all major gaming websites plus xbox live & psn. how come he only went after one? he could’ve made more money by suing the others.

     

    here’s a theoritical settlement: suing author found dead with a logo the shape of a cross inscribed in his forehead. ooohhhh…..

    sprite
  • Profile picture of david_29 david_29 said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    he is fairly going for it this guy haha

    sprite
  • Profile picture of Wolf Wolf said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    We likely won’t hear anything until it’s either been tossed out for a frivoulus suit by the courts, or Ubisoft capitulates and settles- which I hope they do not do.

     

    either way, Ubisoft won’t be able to say anything publicly until after their lawyers have gone over it with a fine toothed comb, if even then. Likely, they’ll never say anything.

    sprite
  • Profile picture of pedgz pedgz said 1 year, 1 month ago ago:

    it would be a funny settlement if ubisoft gives him a copy of all ac-related books released so far (bowden novels, encyclopedia, graphic nover, heck even the comic!).

    sprite